Roma vs Atalanta: The First Real Measure of Two Perfect Starts
Six points apiece gives this third-round meeting a significance that goes beyond an ordinary early-season fixture.
Roma have opened the campaign with consecutive 4-0 league victories over Fiorentina and Lecce, while Atalanta have also won their first two Serie A matches.
Gian Piero Gasperini therefore faces his former club with his new side still unbeaten and yet to concede in the league.
Maurizio Sarri’s Atalanta arrive with the same perfect points total, giving the Olimpico a genuine early test between two sides with European ambitions.
Roma’s advantage is home territory and an attack already producing heavily, while Atalanta bring Sarri’s possession principles and a squad strengthened during the summer.
Gasperini himself described the encounter as a test of strength and quality, and said the result could have importance for Roma’s European ambitions later in the season.
The tactical contrast begins with Roma’s 3-4-2-1 against Atalanta’s 4-3-3.
Roma can use Wesley and Emanuele Lulli to stretch the pitch while Bryan Cristante and Manu Koné provide the central platform behind Paulo Dybala and Rodrigo Mora.
Donyell Malen has been the most visible attacking threat during the opening weeks, giving Roma a forward capable of attacking the space behind the defensive line.
Atalanta can answer through Charles De Ketelaere and Giacomo Raspadori from the front line, with Gianluca Scamacca providing the central reference point.
The midfield duel is equally important, because Lazar Samardžić, Gianluca Gaetano and Éderson must find ways of playing through Roma’s central block without leaving space for Koné to drive forward.
With Sarri favouring possession and Gasperini demanding adaptability from his attacking players, the contest could turn on which side controls the spaces immediately outside the penalty areas.
🩻 Medical Report Before the Olimpico Test
| Roma — Injury Status |
|---|
| Out / Ruled Out | Lorenzo Pellegrini | Still working with the group; not expected to play against Atalanta |
| Atalanta — Injury Status |
|---|
| Out / Ruled Out | Isak Hien | Hamstring injury; continuing rehabilitation and therapy |
| Out / Ruled Out | Kamaldeen Sulemana | Knee injury; continuing rehabilitation and therapy |
Roma’s official pre-match update provides a more positive picture for Paulo Dybala and Evan Ndicka than earlier reports had suggested.
Gasperini said Dybala’s tests showed nothing out of the ordinary and that the Argentine would train, while Ndicka had improved considerably and was expected to be able to play.
Lorenzo Pellegrini is at a different stage, having only begun some work with the group and being considered for a later fixture rather than this match.
Atalanta’s official squad announcement confirms that Isak Hien and Kamaldeen Sulemana were not among the 23 selected players and were continuing therapy.
The two clubs therefore enter the game with relatively manageable availability issues, although Atalanta are missing defensive depth through Hien’s absence.
No additional questionable players are included in the tables because the official club updates do not identify further current injury doubts requiring that category.
🟢 Matchday Choices: The Expected Starting Sides
The official starting XIs had not yet been released at the time of this preview, so the following tables use the latest reported probable formations rather than presenting predictions as confirmed team news.
Roma’s expected structure is the familiar three-man defence with Svilar behind Mancini, Ndicka and Hermoso.
Lulli, Cristante, Koné and Wesley form the projected midfield line, with Dybala and Mora operating behind Malen.
Atalanta are expected to use Carnesecchi behind Zappacosta, Kossounou, Scalvini and Bernasconi.
Sarri’s projected midfield contains Samardžić, Gaetano and Éderson, with De Ketelaere, Scamacca and Raspadori completing the front three.
These are the latest probable XIs, not fabricated confirmations; the final team sheets should be treated as authoritative once officially released.
| Roma — Latest Probable XI |
|---|
| Goalkeeper | Mile Svilar | Goalkeeper |
| Defender | Gianluca Mancini | Centre-back |
| Defender | Evan Ndicka | Centre-back |
| Defender | Mario Hermoso | Centre-back |
| Midfielder | Emanuele Lulli | Wing-back |
| Midfielder | Bryan Cristante | Central midfield |
| Midfielder | Manu Koné | Central midfield |
| Midfielder | Wesley | Wing-back |
| Attacking midfielder | Paulo Dybala | Advanced creator |
| Attacking midfielder | Rodrigo Mora | Advanced creator |
| Forward | Donyell Malen | Centre-forward |
| Atalanta — Latest Probable XI |
|---|
| Goalkeeper | Marco Carnesecchi | Goalkeeper |
| Defender | Davide Zappacosta | Right-back |
| Defender | Odilon Kossounou | Centre-back |
| Defender | Giorgio Scalvini | Centre-back |
| Defender | Lorenzo Bernasconi | Left-back |
| Midfielder | Lazar Samardžić | Central midfield |
| Midfielder | Gianluca Gaetano | Central midfield |
| Midfielder | Éderson | Central midfield |
| Forward | Charles De Ketelaere | Right-sided forward |
| Forward | Gianluca Scamacca | Centre-forward |
| Forward | Giacomo Raspadori | Left-sided forward |
🎯 Players Who Can Bend the Tactical Battle
| Roma — Key Personnel |
|---|
| Category | Player | Importance |
| Coach | Gian Piero Gasperini | Faces his former club in Roma’s first major early-season test |
| Forward | Donyell Malen | Roma’s leading attacking reference after the opening two league games |
| Attacker | Paulo Dybala | Provides creativity between Atalanta’s midfield and defence |
| Midfielder | Manu Koné | Important ball-carrying presence in the central zone |
| Atalanta — Key Personnel |
|---|
| Category | Player | Importance |
| Coach | Maurizio Sarri | Introduces his possession-based ideas against Gasperini’s Roma |
| Forward | Gianluca Scamacca | Central focal point against Roma’s three centre-backs |
| Forward | Charles De Ketelaere | Can attack the spaces around Roma’s midfield line |
| Midfielder | Éderson | Adds ball recovery and forward running from midfield |
- Variation rule: This article is built around the first major head-to-head test of the two perfect league starts, with injuries deliberately kept away from the opening narrative.
- Roma angle: Eight goals scored and none conceded across the first two Serie A matches have given Gasperini’s side an immediate platform.
- Atalanta angle: Sarri’s team also has six points, and the club’s official pre-match material stresses the importance of facing a strong Roma side at the Olimpico.
- Press-room theme: Gasperini called Atalanta a top-level team with significant summer reinforcement, specifically highlighting Franck Kessié and Jonathan Rowe.
- Availability note: Roma’s Dybala and Ndicka received positive updates, while Pellegrini remains in rehabilitation; Atalanta travel without Hien and Sulemana.
The pre-match conversation has centred on whether Roma’s explosive beginning can survive its first heavyweight examination.
Gasperini has openly rejected the idea that this is merely a test of maturity, instead describing it as a contest of strength and quality between sides with serious ambitions.
Sarri, meanwhile, said he was satisfied with Atalanta’s summer work and described the upcoming match as an important and attractive challenge.
Atalanta’s official preview also points to the change of scenery after two home matches to begin their Serie A campaign, making the Olimpico trip their first league assignment away from Bergamo.
The coaches’ comments suggest neither side intends to treat this as a cautious September encounter, even though the season is still only two rounds old.
For Roma, maintaining the attacking sharpness without losing defensive discipline will be crucial; for Atalanta, escaping pressure and establishing Sarri’s passing rhythm could determine whether their perfect start continues to carry weight.